Most active commenters
  • righthand(4)

←back to thread

300 points drewr | 11 comments | | HN request time: 0.961s | source | bottom
Show context
righthand ◴[] No.44409378[source]
This is part of Project 2025 to destroy the NOAA. [0]

> Break up the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration.

> "fully commercialize" the National Weather Service's forecasting operations.[1]

[0] https://www.project2025.observer/?search=NOAA

[1] https://www.project2025.observer/?search=Weather

replies(3): >>44409385 #>>44409438 #>>44409507 #
1. ivape ◴[] No.44409385[source]
What in the actual fuck. I can’t believe they are actually doing all those little petty things.
replies(4): >>44409387 #>>44409390 #>>44409451 #>>44409605 #
2. righthand ◴[] No.44409387[source]
Yes as warned and ignored.
replies(1): >>44409692 #
3. nemomarx ◴[] No.44409390[source]
Genuine - did you think it was exaggerated in the media or that they wouldn't? A lot of people seem to have not taken it seriously around 2023, even though it was a very detailed plan with legal strategies, implementations and bills, etc in there.
replies(2): >>44409397 #>>44414091 #
4. righthand ◴[] No.44409397[source]
A lot of people didn’t take it seriously because the RNC lied about distancing themselves from the Project 2025, which is a meaningless statement that even Democrats believed. It doesn’t really matter if the RNC distances themselves though does it?
5. TheOtherHobbes ◴[] No.44409451[source]
They're not just petty, they're wildly impractical.

You can't privatise NOAA and the services it offers. It cannot work at an equivalent level as a private service. Its effectiveness relies on being able to decide what's valuable in purely scientific terms, and those terms don't align with short-term corporate greed.

But if you ask these cranks what NOAA actually does, they'll have no clue. They're not just evil, they're stupid - the smallest, most banal bureaucrats, cosplaying radicals.

replies(2): >>44409473 #>>44409569 #
6. kelnos ◴[] No.44409473[source]
They're not trying to privatize NOAA; they're trying to shut it down.

NWS is what they're trying to privatize.

replies(1): >>44409497 #
7. righthand ◴[] No.44409497{3}[source]
Yes the conflation is my bad because I think this move is relative to NWS privatization, which is what might strike most people. You can’t have the government predicting and tracking major weather events and issues, those are the biggest datasets to sell access too.

For other NOAA fallout effects in the government, a Potus wouldn’t have to rob from the FEMA funds if there’s nothing for FEMA to prepare for, in that FEMA cannot say we need to spend money to help flooding in Texas or hurricane damage in Florida. No cancel that and put that money into the tax break or 1% monetary “business investment” funnel fund. [0] [1]

[0] https://www.project2025.observer/?search=flood

[1] https://www.project2025.observer/?search=Fema&sort=agency-de...

8. tokai ◴[] No.44409569[source]
>It cannot work [...] as a private service

But with public contracts it can be a very effective way to line ones pockets with tax payer money.

9. ◴[] No.44409605[source]
10. mptest ◴[] No.44409692[source]
Literally had this report for years and literally heard the current president praise and endorse it on a hot mic. The fact that, presumably, educated people, are still acting surprised (or worse, legitimately are ignorant) when the reic-i mean presidency was explicitly planned out, in a commissioned by the wealthy, public to all, report by the most connected conservative think tank in the country.
11. ivape ◴[] No.44414091[source]
They say all cynics used to be idealist. That’s another way of saying the idealist and cynic have the same essence.

The cynic can actually think “oh that project 2025 stuff, that’s just red meat for their base, they went actually do it”, but that’s because neither the cynic nor the idealist can face reality (remember, the cynic and idealist transform between each other).

The horror of reality is the raw hard reality, and there’s no cynicism or idealism that can prepare you for it - both were always a coping mechanism.