←back to thread

94 points mikece | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
GameOfKnowing ◴[] No.44398585[source]
Hey— performer & small site owner here. Most of the hypothetical cases in the media (and these comments) relate to Pornhub, OF, etc— companies that definitely can afford to implement age verification even if it hurts their bottom line. This totally misses the vast majority of porn sites that are very small, operate on licensed technology that may not even be maintained, and would have their ~low-5-digit annual income nuked by the cost of compliance. In these cases, geo-blocking states one by one as they implement these laws becomes the only option. Yeah VPNs exist, but HN users faaaaar over-estimate the technical knowledge & ability of the average American used to having the net served to them on a silver platter.
replies(4): >>44398618 #>>44398642 #>>44398646 #>>44398759 #
1. WarOnPrivacy ◴[] No.44398646[source]
> Yeah VPNs exist, but HN users faaaaar over-estimate the technical knowledge & ability of the average American used to having the net served to them on a silver platter.

We can evaluate this by considering the results of DNS blocking ThePirateBay.

ref: https://kagi.com/search?q=How+effective+was+dns+blocking+the...

replies(1): >>44400905 #
2. raydev ◴[] No.44400905[source]
That's not a reference, it's just a list of search results.

Do you have a direct source for how many Americans accessed TPB after it was DNS blocked in all of the US?

replies(1): >>44405857 #
3. WarOnPrivacy ◴[] No.44405857[source]
> That's not a reference, it's just a list of search results.

Results are references. Links pasted in HN can leave some doubt what's at the other end. Usually that's fine but by presenting those same links thru a search engine, you get some text to help indicate whether they have the info you want.

The results may also include links you would want - but maybe I wouldn't choose.

> Do you have a direct source for how many Americans accessed TPB after it was DNS blocked in all of the US?

This is a very narrow scenario you've presented. It doesn't seem to address the aspects of the thread in a helpful way.