←back to thread

131 points timshell | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
imiric ◴[] No.44378450[source]
I applaud the effort. We need human-friendly CAPTCHAs, as much as they're generally disliked. They're the only solution to the growing spam and abuse problem on the web.

Proof-of-work CAPTCHAs work well for making bots expensive to run at scale, but they still rely on accurate bot detection. Avoiding both false positives and negatives is crucial, yet all existing approaches are not reliable enough.

One comment re:

> While AI agents can theoretically simulate these patterns, the effort likely outweighs other alternatives.

For now. Behavioral and cognitive signals seem to work against the current generation of bots, but will likely also be defeated as AI tools become cheaper and more accessible. It's only a matter of time until attackers can train a model on real human input, and inference to be cheap enough. Or just for the benefit of using a bot on a specific target to outweigh the costs.

So I think we will need a different detection mechanism. Maybe something from the real world, some type of ID, or even micropayments. I'm not sure, but it's clear that bot detection is at the opposite, and currently losing, side of the AI race.

replies(11): >>44378709 #>>44379146 #>>44379545 #>>44380175 #>>44380453 #>>44380659 #>>44380693 #>>44382515 #>>44384051 #>>44387254 #>>44389004 #
1. emrehan ◴[] No.44387254[source]
https://zkpassport.id could be used to prove that you’ve a government ID with NFC capabilities, without revealing anything like your nation.

https://docs.zkpassport.id/faq https://docs.zkpassport.id/examples/personhood

replies(1): >>44387906 #
2. codedokode ◴[] No.44387906[source]
I hope people have some self-respect not to show their ID to use a website.