←back to thread

282 points bundie | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.463s | source
Show context
zeroq ◴[] No.44385875[source]
I'm not sold on Better Auth.

Recently I wanted to add auth to my pet project, and between (a) using better-auth, then integrating 3rd party mailer service, and rolling out my main dashboard (b) leeching off free tier of Auth0 or Clerk and getting all batteries included I've chose the latter.

The fact that better-auth doesn't come with barebone dashboard is criminal.

For pet project it doesn't matter if I have to integrate Resend or Clerk, it's still some mental overhead I have to account for, but with Clerk at least I don't have to manage my users using sql queries.

People say it's better because you can embed it in your app. I don't buy that either. If I'd have to rollout better-auth I'd do that as a separate app, just to encapsulate database, dashboard, and integrations.

Anyway, glad it's getting traction, I just don't get all the hype around it.

replies(4): >>44386269 #>>44386288 #>>44386561 #>>44387916 #
1. notpushkin ◴[] No.44386269[source]
If Better Auth came with a simple builtin email implementation (i.e. just plug in SMTP credentials), I’d consider it perfect. (I’m not sold on Resend!)

Agreed that a builtin dashboard would be nice, but it’s not necessary by any means – you’ll still be building your own dashboard around your ORM models, which is of course what Better Auth uses, too.

But if you’re looking for something more like Clerk, maybe try Logto or Authentik?

replies(1): >>44418444 #
2. zeroq ◴[] No.44418444[source]
After your post I made it back to logto to see that I've already have account in their system. Then I looked around and I still have no clue what their offering is about. Seriously, it's so "AI", "MCP", "SaaS" oriented that I'm absolutely clueless what the offering is.