←back to thread

494 points todsacerdoti | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
wyldfire ◴[] No.44382903[source]
I understand where this comes from but I think it's a mistake. I agree it would be nice if there were "well settled law" regarding AI and copyright, probably relatively few rulings and next to zero legislation on which to base their feelings.

In addition to a policy to reject contributions from AI, I think it may make sense to point out places where AI generated content can be used. For example - how much of QEMU project's (copious) CI setup is really stuff that is critical content to protect? What about ever-more interesting test cases or environments that could be enabled? Something like "contribute those things here instead, and make judicious use of AI there, with these kinds of guard rails..."

replies(5): >>44382957 #>>44382958 #>>44383166 #>>44383312 #>>44383370 #
kazinator ◴[] No.44382958[source]
There is a well settled practice in computing that you just don't plagiarize code. Even a small snippet. Even if copyright law would consider such a small thing "fair use".
replies(2): >>44383103 #>>44383321 #
bfLives ◴[] No.44383321[source]
> There is a well settled practice in computing that you just don't plagiarize code. Even a small snippet.

I think way many developers use StackOverflow suggests otherwise.

replies(1): >>44383415 #
kazinator ◴[] No.44383415[source]
In the first place, in order to post to StackOverflow, you are required to have the copyright over the code, and be able to grant them a perpetual license.

They redistribute the material under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/

This allows visitors to use the material, with attribution. One can, of course, use the ideas in a SO answer to develop one's own solution.

replies(2): >>44384260 #>>44385322 #
1. graemep ◴[] No.44385322[source]
> you are required to have the copyright over the code, and be able to grant them a perpetual license.

Which Stack Overflow cannot verify. It might be pulled from a code base, or generated by AI (I would bet a lot is now).