←back to thread

A new PNG spec

(www.programmax.net)
616 points bluedel | 3 comments | | HN request time: 1.552s | source
1. remram ◴[] No.44378467[source]
So what do we call it? PNG3? The spec is titled "Portable Network Graphics Specification (Third Edition)".

Surely they aren't releasing a new, incompatible version and expecting us to pretend it's the same format...?

> This updates the existing image/png Internet Media type

whyyyyyyy

replies(1): >>44380093 #
2. ProgramMax ◴[] No.44380093[source]
New? Yes. Incompatible? No.

We went to pretty extreme lengths to make sure old software worked with the new changes. Effectively, the limit will be the software, not the image.

For example, you can imagine some old software that is unaware of color spaces and treats everything as sRGB. There is nothing we can do to make that software show a Display P3 correctly. However, we can still show the image well enough that a user understands "that is a red apple".

replies(1): >>44386196 #
3. account42 ◴[] No.44386196[source]
Having images show up in washed up colors without any indication is not what I'd consider "working". This mistake has been made many times, please let's not make it again.