←back to thread

A new PNG spec

(www.programmax.net)
614 points bluedel | 8 comments | | HN request time: 0.984s | source | bottom
Show context
poisonborz ◴[] No.44375523[source]
Not backwards compatible. We just add it to that nice cupboard "great advanced image formats we will forget about".

Society doesn't need a new image format. I'd wager to say not any new multimedia format. Big corporate entites do, and have churning them out at a steady pace.

Look at poor webp - a format pushed by the largest industry players - and the abysmal everyday use it gets, and the hate it generates.

replies(10): >>44375537 #>>44375557 #>>44375998 #>>44376442 #>>44376512 #>>44376957 #>>44376999 #>>44377083 #>>44377151 #>>44380128 #
michaelmior ◴[] No.44375537[source]
> and the abysmal everyday use it gets

Estimates are that 95% of Internet users have a browser that supports WebP and that ~25% of the top million websites serve WebP images. I wouldn't call that abysmal.

replies(5): >>44375570 #>>44375590 #>>44375752 #>>44376063 #>>44376879 #
1. hsbauauvhabzb ◴[] No.44375570[source]
My file manager can’t handle them but my browser can.

Edit: and good luck uploading the format to the majority of webforms that aren’t faang.

replies(3): >>44376185 #>>44376400 #>>44386104 #
2. debugnik ◴[] No.44376185[source]
Not even Google supports webp uploads in many of their web apps, and it's their format.
replies(1): >>44376548 #
3. upcoming-sesame ◴[] No.44376400[source]
If you are using an image optimization service like Imgix / Cloudflare Image Resizing then it doesn't really matter, image can be uploaded as any supported format and will be sent to the end user according to their "Accept" header
replies(1): >>44377431 #
4. chillingeffect ◴[] No.44376548[source]
Could it be a lack of resources? Or some missing expertise? Maybe they could find some interns who are familiar with it? Maybe the entire world is so obsessed w AI, we don't even care about image formats anymore.
replies(1): >>44376861 #
5. pixl97 ◴[] No.44376861{3}[source]
Honestly this kind of stuff happens all the time in large companies.

Interns won't want to work on a dead end like this. Moreso they need to be supervised by someone that doesn't want to get removed by being the lowest X% usefulness in a company. So all these existing tools that aren't primary revenue generators just sit on coast mode.

6. hsbauauvhabzb ◴[] No.44377431[source]
if you’d like to go and implement that in all the millions of existing web apps, go ahead?

Let’s also not forget the dependency mess that leaves in applications before we do though..

7. account42 ◴[] No.44386104[source]
Demand more from you file manager then.
replies(1): >>44386788 #
8. hsbauauvhabzb ◴[] No.44386788[source]
Sure, ur then it’s my image viewer, my phones image viewer, the website I try and upload pictures to. This isn’t a problem you can solve by patching one application, and it’s not one the world as a whole cares about.

Better image formats serve entities who store images at scale, not end users.