←back to thread

122 points jbegley | 4 comments | | HN request time: 0.456s | source
Show context
omegaworks ◴[] No.44370994[source]
Worth it to keep in mind as well, that Iran was committed under the NPT to limit nuclear development to non-weapons based usage. They were inspected regularly by UN bodies like the IAEA and the conclusions of our own intelligence agencies did not support the assertion that they were developing a weapon.

They were using it to support a legitimate nuclear energy and radiotheraputics industry. They are in the part of the planet that will be most impacted by climate warming, so nuclear is critical for them to support baseline power needs.

The United States striking these sites throws the entire international system of non-proliferation into question. If there is no commitment any country can make to any system of governance that allows for peaceful development of nuclear energy, there is no controlling nuclear weapons development and proliferation.

Nowhere in this CNN brief are we informed about whether the sites were or were not used for weapons development. If we take the lessons of mainstream media's coverage of the Iraq war, it is likely CNN is stating this because their owners have been told that it would be better for their bottom line to manufacture consent for a second round of strikes than to preserve the President's assertion that the strikes were successful.

replies(1): >>44371096 #
votepaunchy ◴[] No.44371096[source]
There are no civilian uses for these large quantities of 60% enriched uranium.
replies(1): >>44371487 #
1. deftnerd ◴[] No.44371487[source]
Civilian uses? Perhaps not, but Iran has always wanted to have a respected navy. Compact nuclear reactors like the type used in submarines with nuclear reactors for their power production require 90%+ enriched uranium. That's one very plausible use of HEU that isn't just "they want to build a bomb".
replies(3): >>44372028 #>>44379284 #>>44379325 #
2. 7e ◴[] No.44372028[source]
A submarine is a good place to hide a breeder reactor. Far from any detectors.
3. ◴[] No.44379284[source]
4. giardini ◴[] No.44379325[source]
deftnerd says>Iran has always wanted to have a respected navy.<

They couldn't find enough men who could swim!