←back to thread

523 points sva_ | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.22s | source
Show context
Zaheer ◴[] No.44314495[source]
Original DHS Announcement on Social Media Screening: https://www.uscis.gov/newsroom/news-releases/dhs-to-begin-sc...

State Dept on what is considered Antisemitism: https://www.state.gov/defining-antisemitism/

These definitions are intentionally broad and designed to censor criticism of Israel. You have more freedom to criticize the US Government than to criticize a foreign country.

replies(13): >>44314526 #>>44314820 #>>44315087 #>>44315104 #>>44315309 #>>44315447 #>>44315680 #>>44316478 #>>44316738 #>>44318457 #>>44319156 #>>44322666 #>>44327381 #
WatchDog ◴[] No.44315447[source]
Wow these are incredibly broad, in particular:

> Accusing Jewish citizens of being more loyal to Israel, or to the alleged priorities of Jews worldwide, than to the interests of their own nations.

There are plenty of dual citizens that would proudly admit that their first loyalty is to Israel.

Other examples from the document use the term "Jews as a people", whereas this example seems to apply to accusing any individual.

Although perhaps a generous interpretation of the example, is that it excludes Israeli dual citizens, because Israel would be one of "their own nations"

replies(11): >>44315473 #>>44315607 #>>44316273 #>>44316424 #>>44316880 #>>44316897 #>>44317292 #>>44318124 #>>44318487 #>>44323278 #>>44323640 #
1. Aloisius ◴[] No.44323640[source]
The preface to the list of examples is rather important:

> Contemporary examples of antisemitism ... could, taking into account the overall context, include...:

Context is important. The examples are not true in all cases, but rather context dependent.

Accusing Jewish citizens of your country of being more loyal to Israel than their country simply because they're Jewish? Antisemitic.

Accusing a specific Jewish citizen that has said they are more loyal to Israel? Not antisemitic.