←back to thread

1480 points sandslash | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.204s | source
Show context
tudorizer ◴[] No.44319472[source]
95% terrible expression of the landscape, 5% neatly dumbed down analogies.

English is a terrible language for deterministic outcomes in complex/complicated systems. Vibe coders won't understand this until they are 2 years into building the thing.

LLMs have their merits and he sometimes aludes to them, although it almost feels accidental.

Also, you don't spend years studying computer science to learn the language/syntax, but rather the concepts and systems, which don't magically disappear with vibe coding.

This whole direction is a cheeky Trojan horse. A dramatic problem, hidden in a flashy solution, to which a fix will be upsold 3 years from now.

I'm excited to come back to this comment in 3 years.

replies(10): >>44319579 #>>44319777 #>>44320017 #>>44320108 #>>44320322 #>>44320523 #>>44320547 #>>44320613 #>>44320728 #>>44320743 #
qjack ◴[] No.44320728[source]
While I agree with you broadly, remember that those that employ you don't have those skills either. They accept that they are ceding control of the details and trust us to make those decisions or ask clarifying questions (LLMs are getting better at those things too). Vibe coders are clients seeking an alternative, not developers.
replies(2): >>44320767 #>>44320840 #
1. tudorizer ◴[] No.44320767[source]
> Vibe coders are clients seeking an alternative, not developers.

Agreed. That's genuinely a good framing for clients.