←back to thread

1479 points sandslash | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0.652s | source
Show context
gchamonlive ◴[] No.44314670[source]
I think it's interesting to juxtapose traditional coding, neural network weights and prompts because in many areas -- like the example of the self driving module having code being replaced by neural networks tuned to the target dataset representing the domain -- this will be quite useful.

However I think it's important to make it clear that given the hardware constraints of many environments the applicability of what's being called software 2.0 and 3.0 will be severely limited.

So instead of being replacements, these paradigms are more like extra tools in the tool belt. Code and prompts will live side by side, being used when convenient, but none a panacea.

replies(4): >>44315052 #>>44316337 #>>44322007 #>>44323973 #
karpathy ◴[] No.44315052[source]
I kind of say it in words (agreeing with you) but I agree the versioning is a bit confusing analogy because it usually additionally implies some kind of improvement. When I’m just trying to distinguish them as very different software categories.
replies(5): >>44315296 #>>44319138 #>>44319445 #>>44320206 #>>44320915 #
poorcedural ◴[] No.44319138[source]
Andrej, maybe Software 3.0 is not written in spoken language like code or prompts. Software 3.0 is recorded in behavior, a behavior that today's software lacks. That behavior is written and consumed by machine and annotated by human interaction. Skipping to 3.0 is premature, but Software 2.0 is a ramp.
replies(1): >>44319217 #
1. mclau157 ◴[] No.44319217[source]
Would this also be more of a push towards robotics and getting physical AI in our every day lives
replies(1): >>44319293 #
2. poorcedural ◴[] No.44319293[source]
Very insightful! How you would describe boiling an egg is different than how a machine would describe it to another machine.
replies(1): >>44323950 #
3. fc417fc802 ◴[] No.44323950[source]
Funny that you should use boiling an egg as an example. https://www.nature.com/articles/s44172-024-00334-w