←back to thread

849 points dvektor | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.21s | source
Show context
chatmasta ◴[] No.44289323[source]
How does the compensation work? The US prison system has a bit of a nasty reputation when it comes to exploiting prison labor, so I hope those practices aren’t carrying over into these more forward-looking types of initiative… but at the same time, surely Turso isn’t paying full SWE salary?
replies(4): >>44289450 #>>44289601 #>>44289611 #>>44290062 #
laufey ◴[] No.44289450[source]
Just curious, why would you expect him to be paid less? I know historically pay is bad for prisoners, but if he's working the same hours and is just as productive as any other employee, shouldn't he be paid the same? I could potentially see paying someone less if they were coming in with much less experience than what's usually hired for in the role, but that doesn't seem to be the case here.
replies(10): >>44289471 #>>44289474 #>>44289478 #>>44289497 #>>44289600 #>>44289616 #>>44289680 #>>44290042 #>>44290080 #>>44292241 #
wffurr ◴[] No.44289497[source]
The 13th amendment specifically allows slavery of prisoners.

Edit: I don’t mean to imply the author isn’t paid fairly by Turso. A few posts down, the CEO of Turso asserts that they do pay fairly. The OP in this thread might reasonably wonder about this because several states do in fact use prisoners as unpaid slave labor.

replies(3): >>44289623 #>>44290145 #>>44290587 #
pyuser583 ◴[] No.44290587[source]
It's unclear whether the carve out for prisoners applies to just "involuntary servitude" or "slavery and involuntary servitude."

In practice, only "involuntary servitude" has been used. "Community service" - unpaid - is a very common low level sentence.

The eighth and fourteenth amendments almost certainly forbid enslavement - permanently becoming human property - as a criminal sentence.

Even before the 13th amendment, enslavement as a punishment not common, if it happened at all.

There is almost no case law on the 13th amendment. There are no legal slaves in the US today, and there have not been since the 19th century.

replies(1): >>44290741 #
tristan957 ◴[] No.44290741[source]
If we pay people 40 cents an hour just to say they aren't slaves, they they are slaves for all intents and purposes. They are put in poor working conditions working for for-profit companies, making much less than minimum wage. How is it legal for the State to not provide sunscreen or shade for inmates doing outdoor manual labor?

https://theappeal.org/louisiana-prisoners-demand-an-end-to-m...

replies(2): >>44290853 #>>44293956 #
brulard ◴[] No.44293956[source]
A prisoner costs taxpayers around $50k a year on average in US. If their "take-home" wage is $0.40/h, it may still be generous.
replies(1): >>44296272 #
const_cast ◴[] No.44296272[source]
That cost should be taken by our government and the tax payer, as a disincentive to locking people up.

If you can lock someone up and get close to free labor for it, then we're going to start locking a lot of people up. I mean, it's free labor. Which is why we used to give people 20 years for possession of marijuana. What, you think it's just a coincidence we were throwing primarily black Americans away in prison for ludicrous amounts of time where they'll spend their days picking cotton?

That's what happens when imprisoning people is cheap.

replies(2): >>44298240 #>>44300867 #
pyuser583 ◴[] No.44298240[source]
Do you think prisoners are literally picking cotton?
replies(2): >>44302520 #>>44303737 #
1. const_cast ◴[] No.44302520[source]
I don’t think, they literally are. Feel free to look it up. Our prison labor systems in the south are direct descendants of Jim Crow era America.