←back to thread

849 points dvektor | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.225s | source
Show context
mlissner ◴[] No.44289885[source]
Maine's remote work program is an incredibly promising development to prevent recidivism. The amazing thing about it is that it gives real jobs to prisoners that they can seamlessly continue after they get out of prison. Normally when you get out, it's impossible to get a job, and the clock is ticking. This leads to desperation, which leads to bad behavior.

There is a real risk of exploitation, but if it's properly managed, remote work for prisoners is one of the most hopeful things I've heard about the prison system. It gives people purpose while there and an avenue to success once they're out.

replies(7): >>44290046 #>>44290150 #>>44291513 #>>44291690 #>>44293165 #>>44293193 #>>44293353 #
dfxm12 ◴[] No.44290150[source]
Do participants get paid a real wage?
replies(1): >>44290225 #
glommer ◴[] No.44290225[source]
Preston was free to negotiate his pay with us, and we pay him a full salary. Just no health care benefits.
replies(2): >>44290487 #>>44290988 #
dgacmu ◴[] No.44290487[source]
Does he actually get the salary, or does the prison take huge overhead?
replies(2): >>44290547 #>>44290868 #
glommer ◴[] No.44290547[source]
they take an (actually very reasonable) cut, but he is free to take his salary.
replies(2): >>44290606 #>>44292364 #
kgwxd ◴[] No.44290606[source]
No cut is reasonable.
replies(6): >>44290689 #>>44290761 #>>44290790 #>>44290903 #>>44291361 #>>44291420 #
hashstring ◴[] No.44290761[source]
Why would it not be reasonable?
replies(1): >>44291692 #
hildolfr ◴[] No.44291692[source]
Google feeds staff members and provides rest areas , why are they paid?
replies(3): >>44291970 #>>44292371 #>>44293634 #
borski ◴[] No.44292371[source]
The government takes a cut then too, both from the employer and employer, in the form of taxes.
replies(1): >>44293444 #
kgwxd ◴[] No.44293444[source]
Which should be paying for the prisons and the operations society approves of to reform inmates. Prisons should not be a businesses of any kind.
replies(1): >>44293704 #
1. hashstring ◴[] No.44293704[source]
I agree that a prison should not be a business (aka a different model than the US-model). I also think that many prisoners are currently treated unfairly.

However, ideally, I don’t think that it makes sense for someone to go to prison, which costs tax money, and meanwhile earn the same amount of money by remote working from prison as someone in the outside world, who actually has living expenses to pay for (which get taxed also).

So, I think, when it comes to fairness, it wouldn’t be unreasonable if a partial cut goes to the TCOO of holding that prisoner.

Now again, American prisons have their whole incentive model messed up, so I don’t even want to get in an argument about America’s implementation of this system and how it would lead to more problems— because it’s well-known and more than expected.