←back to thread

526 points cactusplant7374 | 4 comments | | HN request time: 0.353s | source
Show context
probably_wrong ◴[] No.44076946[source]
I think the author is arguing against their own point with the illustration they chose. The very last picture can be found in the Wikipedia page for the Homestead Act and, two jumps later, one can find themselves in the Dutch version of "Sod house" [1] which has this to say:

> The living conditions there were miserable. Due to the construction method, the room was difficult to heat, it was damp and teeming with vermin. (...) The Housing Act of 1901 prohibited living in sod huts.

If the author says "you can live like your grandparents" to mean "in conditions that were already considered miserable for the standards of 1901", that's not a great selling point. And while I sympathize with the underlying message to a point, I would argue against romanticizing the past. Sure, my grandfather lived in a cheap house he built himself, but he also came back home every day with bleeding fingers that my grandmother would treat.

[1] https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plaggenhut

replies(5): >>44077162 #>>44077334 #>>44077677 #>>44081152 #>>44081880 #
1. testing22321 ◴[] No.44081152[source]
I lived in a place purely heated by a wood stove in the Yukon. It was glorious, easily best heat and nicest feel ever. When it was past -40 I’d get up at 1am to put in more wood, otherwise I’d have to spend 30 minutes in the morning lighting it again.

Places heated with wood stoves are NOT damp or miserable. I loved it. Working on doing it again.

replies(2): >>44081574 #>>44095642 #
2. oneshotpez ◴[] No.44081574[source]
Wow tending a fire 24/7 so I don’t die. Living the life, yo.
replies(1): >>44082903 #
3. testing22321 ◴[] No.44082903[source]
I Put wood in it twice a day in winter three when it was proper cold. Never in summer. New ones that have a catalytic combustor go 24 hours without touching them easy.

Also you miss the point. For tending the wood stove a few times a day in winter I got to not go to work 30 hours a week.

4. Doxin ◴[] No.44095642[source]
> Places heated with wood stoves are NOT damp or miserable.

A vaguely well constructed place with a wood stove doesn't have to be damp and miserable. A sod hut is going to be. Imagine a tent except it has grass sod for a roof. It's going to be moist all the time.

Plenty of ye olden construction and heating methods are perfectly fine even today. A sod hut is not one of them.