←back to thread

526 points cactusplant7374 | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
owenversteeg ◴[] No.44077762[source]
Like other people here, I have my quibbles with the exact math. But the general premise is true: yes, you can live in rural poverty for cheap. The problem is the vibes. A hundred years ago, you would have a community, a place in society, and all of your family and friends nearby. In 2025, the only actual local job the author of the piece can come up with is at a gas station.

Top ten occupations, 1920: Farmers, farm laborers, clerks, salespeople, servants (bellboys, butlers, cooks), textile workers, machinists, carpenters, and teachers. All of those jobs, even the less respected ones, had infinitely more societal respect than the common jobs hiring in rural America today - such as stocking shelves at Walmart or working at a gas station. You could be a simple farm laborer and have a wife and kids and a place in society. Today, though, a young man working at a Walmart or a gas station will struggle to attract a stable partner or the respect of the world around him.

replies(5): >>44078785 #>>44079781 #>>44080027 #>>44080066 #>>44081183 #
tuna74 ◴[] No.44080066[source]
"You could be a simple farm laborer and have a wife and kids and a place in society."

You could not afford a good life as a farm laborer.

replies(1): >>44080906 #
1. wyclif ◴[] No.44080906[source]
I don't think the OP was suggesting it would be a good life if by "good" you mean a life of relative comfort. I think his claim was much more modest. The point is that at that time a farm laborer was valued by the local community.
replies(1): >>44081033 #
2. tuna74 ◴[] No.44081033[source]
Farm laborers were probably at the bottom of the social ladder for working rural people. They were usually fully dependent on the owner of the farm that they worked on. Think of the cowboys in the bunkhouse in "Yellowstone" except way worse.
replies(1): >>44085352 #
3. sarchertech ◴[] No.44085352[source]
That’s exactly right. Especially during the time my great grandparents were young—the Great Depression. A farm laborer certainly wasn’t a respected member of society. Many of them became hobos traveling from town to town looking for any work they could find.