←back to thread

526 points cactusplant7374 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.211s | source
Show context
ydlr ◴[] No.44075060[source]
There is a little bit of a sleight of hand going on in this article by claiming the lifestyle of boomers is within reach, but then actually using boomers' parents and grand-parents as the standard. It would be more honest to say "Most of us can't have the relative wealth of our grand parents, but with some sacrifices and creativity, the lifestyle of our great-grand parents is attainable."

Even that is only true in a very narrow sense. My great-grand parents built a 600sqft house in a small town and lived their most of their lives. But they built that house right next to their parents. They lived within 5 miles of their combined 9 siblings. They were within half a mile of their church and half mile from the my great-grandfather's union hall. The town was small, but thriving, with multiple department stores downtown. My great-grandmother worked in two of them.

They did not isolate themselves into a dying town with few opportunities far away from their friends and family.

What millinials and zoomers are really struggling with is the hallowing out of the social and economic institutions that supported our collective wealth and well-being. These struggles may manifest as complaints about the individual ability to afford housing, healthcare, education, etc. But there are not individual solutions to these problems. They are structural.

replies(4): >>44075205 #>>44075953 #>>44076345 #>>44084126 #
yupitsme123 ◴[] No.44075953[source]
The communities that they lived in were more self-sufficient and probably lived outside of the influence of large government or corporations or lobbying groups.

The flourishing town probably grew that way organically, not because of government support or because some company opened a big facility there.

It's true that land is more expensive now, but even if you could buy your own town and settle people on it, organic growth is basically illegal or impossible nowadays.

replies(1): >>44076489 #
ydlr ◴[] No.44076489[source]
Actually, the town basically existed because of the TVA. It was a major employer and profits went to fund the schools and library.
replies(1): >>44076753 #
1. nkurz ◴[] No.44076753[source]
Coincidentally, there was an interesting article about the relationship between Massena and their power company here a few months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42992032

They have a publicly operated utility that seems to be working well for them. It's a good story! Direct link: https://nysfocus.com/2023/06/21/public-power-utility-massena...