←back to thread

292 points nexo-v1 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
ivyirwin ◴[] No.44070709[source]
I was hoping the article was going to be about a physical device as well as the software to manage and play songs. A few years ago I wanted to get my 10 year old son an mp3 player – he's really into listening to music but wasn't ready (still isn't) for a phone. I was shocked by the state of the mp3 player options. When Apple discontinued the iPod they created a huge vacuum that no one seems to have filled.

I think the iPos shuffle (usb stick form) is still the best mp3 player I ever had – it was small, pluggable without extra cords, and battery lasted a really long time. It didn't have a screen to browse music but that was part of the idea – just let the shuffle do its thing. Even this relatively simple concept has not been replicated in the hardware market.

People will say it's not a hardware problem but a software/drm issue. I think that's a real shame. I wish there were a good, inexpensive, portable device that would just play my music.

replies(7): >>44070769 #>>44070776 #>>44070920 #>>44071326 #>>44071414 #>>44071559 #>>44083187 #
1. TheDong ◴[] No.44070769[source]
> When Apple discontinued the iPod they created a huge vacuum that no one seems to have filled.

I think the real shift here isn't the iPod vanishing.

I think the existence of Spotify and smartphones is what killed mp3 players. Both of those just filled so much of the air in the room that it smothered everything else out.