←back to thread

306 points dxs | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.209s | source
Show context
binkHN ◴[] No.44068949[source]
Nice breakdown. I'm new to Linux and didn't know about this:

> Flatpak still uses PulseAudio even if a host system uses PipeWire. The problem with that is that PulseAudio bundles together access to speakers and microphones—you can have access to both, or neither, but not just one. So if an application has access to play sound, it also has access to capture audio

That's a pretty decent sized hole.

replies(1): >>44069013 #
gjsman-1000 ◴[] No.44069013[source]
I sometimes see Linux users sneering at Windows and Mac design mistakes or lack of “freedom”… but then there’s stuff like this.

Of course, Linux is then conveniently redefined in a way that nobody can be responsible, with finger pointing on every issue, rather than admit design flaws like this plague Linux as a whole.

replies(3): >>44069126 #>>44069129 #>>44069527 #
bee_rider ◴[] No.44069129[source]
I get that you already preempted this, but: Flatpack is a weird extra layer on top of Linux. Most distros have package managers that work just fine. These package managers predate Flatpack and basically are the main thing that the distro provides (other than the community, of course).
replies(4): >>44069155 #>>44069490 #>>44069854 #>>44071245 #
AlienRobot ◴[] No.44069490[source]
>Flatpack is a weird extra layer on top of Linux

My brother in christ, systemd, x11 and even GNU are weird extra layers on top of Linux. Linux is just the kernel. This is exactly what "redefining Linux so it's never responsible for 99% you need to put on top of Linux to have a functional modern OS" is about.

replies(2): >>44069786 #>>44070783 #
1. bee_rider ◴[] No.44069786[source]
I explicitly acknowledged that in the other half of the sentence you partially quoted.

I also explained why I thought it was not really right to focus on the deficiencies of Flatpack… so, I’m not sure what the point in repeating that would be. In conclusion,

> Linux is […] exactly what […] you need

I agree!