←back to thread

126 points voxadam | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
baxtr ◴[] No.44054307[source]
Instead of petawatts I’d love to hear what it can destroy.

I imagine a scale like:

1: Mosquito

10000: Planet (Death Star)

replies(1): >>44054678 #
vlmutolo ◴[] No.44054678[source]
To kill a mosquito, you need "a few tens of millijoules, delivered within a few milliseconds" [0], so let's say 10W. To destroy the Earth (so that it turns into scattered dust and never reforms) you need about 10^32 J [1]; if we assume this is applied over maybe 100s, the laser would be 10^30W.

So the log10 scale goes from 1–30, where mosquitos die at 1 and the Earth dies at 30. The 2 PW in the article is about a 15.3. The Vulcan 20-20 project (set to complete in 2029) will register at about 20PW, or a 16.3 on the mosquito-Death Star scale [2].

So on a log scale, we're over halfway to building the Death Star.

[0]: https://spectrum.ieee.org/backyard-star-wars

[1]: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-much-energy-w...

[2]: https://news.sky.com/story/worlds-most-powerful-laser-to-be-...

replies(7): >>44054836 #>>44055427 #>>44055458 #>>44055607 #>>44055831 #>>44056478 #>>44056479 #
1. SamBam ◴[] No.44055831[source]
> if we assume this is applied over maybe 100s

I think this is the crux of the assumption right here. It sounds like this is apply for well under a nanosecond.

I think we're closer to maybe killing a mosquito than "half way to building a Death Star on a log scale" (which, I guess is already much closer to a mosquito than a planet).