←back to thread

126 points voxadam | 5 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
owenversteeg ◴[] No.44055538[source]
I see a number of comments here misunderstanding the power of this laser. Laser facilities like this one are designed for incredibly short pulses that are femtoseconds long, and total energy per pulse is typically on the order of tens of joules, roughly equivalent to a few seconds of your phone flashlight. They can’t destroy much of anything on human scales. They are made to do physics research, and there is absolutely no pathway from a 2 petawatt laser that delivers a few joules a minute to a 2 petawatt laser that hits full output power for a few seconds: that would be 10^16 times more energy, and of course that brief pulse would use more electricity than all the US uses in a year and completely destroy the University of Michigan in spectacular fashion (very roughly equivalent to a five megaton nuclear explosion.)

If you’re interested in the most energy per pulse, you want the “most energetic” laser, which is the NIF at LLNL. That’s about 2 megajoules per pulse or half a kilowatt hour. Definitely enough to kill a mosquito, but it doesn’t even register on the scale of Death Star style lasers from fiction.

And if you want the most destructive power, those are all military lasers. Which can absolutely destroy things science fiction style, but on a fairly small scale and with some important limitations.

replies(8): >>44055592 #>>44055946 #>>44056450 #>>44056467 #>>44056481 #>>44056484 #>>44057017 #>>44058497 #
1. babyent ◴[] No.44055592[source]
So.. We just need to figure out wormholes and make an infinite loop the laser goes through and harness its true power!!
replies(1): >>44055741 #
2. Dylan16807 ◴[] No.44055741[source]
I understand that you're being silly, but even in this silly theory land how is that supposed to work? While the laser is in a loop it's not hitting anything, and if you let it out it's the same as when you put it in.
replies(2): >>44055807 #>>44055960 #
3. babyent ◴[] No.44055807[source]
You're right, I am being silly because I am too uneducated to really make sense of any of it.

I love smart people who work on this stuff, a lot of what I take for granted is due to their efforts :)

4. z2 ◴[] No.44055960[source]
I figure it's a matter of stacking/charging the laser in that loop with a lot of pulses, then letting that all out at once? Like, what if we shot pulses into the orbit of a mini black hole, but then managed to unwind it back out into a single direction?
replies(1): >>44056413 #
5. Dylan16807 ◴[] No.44056413{3}[source]
In that case the problem is you're only charging the loop with about 1 watt of laser on average. It's going to take two weeks just to reach a megajoule. So you can do one really cool shot, and then you have to wait months.