←back to thread

316 points skarat | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.204s | source

Things are changing so fast with these vscode forks I m barely able to keep up. Which one are you guys using currently? How does the autocomplete etc, compare between the two?
Show context
pembrook ◴[] No.43960296[source]
For a time windsurf was way ahead of cursor in full agentic coding, but now I hear cursor has caught up. I have yet to switch back to try out cursor again but starting to get frustrated with Windsurf being restricted to gathering context only 100-200 lines at a time.

So many of the bugs and poor results that it can introduce are simply due to improper context. When forcibly giving it the necessary context you can clearly see it’s not a model problem but it’s a problem with the approach of gathering disparate 100 line snippets at a time.

Also, it struggles with files over 800ish lines which is extremely annoying

We need some smart deepseek-like innovation in context gathering since the hardware and cost of tokens is the real bottleneck here.

replies(2): >>43965526 #>>43966209 #
evolve2k ◴[] No.43965526[source]
Wait, are these 800 lines of code? Am I the only one seeing that as a major code smell? Assuming these are code files, the issue is not AI processing power but rather bread and butter coding practices related to file organisation and modularisation.
replies(3): >>43965878 #>>43982641 #>>44046979 #
1. ThomasRedstone ◴[] No.44046979[source]
The people editing 800+ line files often didn't write them, legacy codebases often stink!

I've dealt with a few over the years with 30k+ line long files, always aiming to refactor that into something more sensible, but that's only possible over a long time.