←back to thread

386 points carabiner | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
FilosofumRex ◴[] No.44011514[source]
MIT is hiding its own culpability by throwing the Student under the proverbial bus. Acemoglu and Autor who are notorious attention seekers and very media savvy and wealthy profs had vouched for him. There is no way a 2nd year PhD students could have pulled this off on his own without a trace of his whereabouts and contacts in the industry.

A cursory review of the first paragraph of the abstract of his single author paper should've set off alarms:

"AI-assisted researchers discover 44% more materials, resulting in a 39% increase in patent filings and a 17% rise in downstream product innovation".

Anyone with rudimentary familiarity with industrial materials science research would have suspected those double digit numbers - even single digit improvements are extremely rare.

replies(3): >>44011614 #>>44012232 #>>44019511 #
mizzao ◴[] No.44011614[source]
This is a recording of a seminar on this paper the author gave via zoom:

https://cassyni.com/events/MiPYGu3qzKP5MQFWNUn9Tb

In retrospect, there seems to be a tell that when he's lying he won't look at the screen/camera: his eyes go up, left, right, anywhere but forward. What I find scary is that this practice of extemporaneous fabrication may be a well-ingrained habit at this point that isn't limited to the scientific realm of the author's life.

replies(3): >>44013521 #>>44014960 #>>44021642 #
1. FilosofumRex ◴[] No.44021642[source]
Here is the original coverage by wsj, note the shody reporting and absence of independent review or opinion by anyone not affiliated by MIT.

“It’s fantastic,” said Acemoglu. “I was floored,” said Autor.

https://www.wsj.com/economy/will-ai-help-hurt-workers-income...

Clearly, Lahart is a journalistic tool and charlatan, so he's @ the right place:

  "Justin Lahart is an economics reporter based in New York. Previously, Justin 
   was a Heard on the Street columnist and wrote the Ahead of the Tape column."