←back to thread

329 points beeburrt | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.406s | source
Show context
rwarfield ◴[] No.44002548[source]
We have normalized the treatment of the financial and payments systems as things that exist primarily to perform law enforcement surveillance functions. It's the same dynamic that leads to debanking of small accounts - payments firms exist on thin margins and the potential fines for inadvertently servicing a bad actor are stratospheric, so it's entirely logical to play it safe by refusing to service anyone whose profile looks even the slightest bit risky.
replies(8): >>44002574 #>>44002616 #>>44002858 #>>44002883 #>>44002926 #>>44003438 #>>44006920 #>>44009595 #
elric ◴[] No.44002858[source]
Debanking small accounts isn't something that I'd heard of before. But debanking "undesirables" is certainly a problem.

Over here (Belgium) we have legalized prostitution, but it's very hard for sex workers to open a bank account. There's some legislation that forces banks to offer them a basic bank account (at a steep fee) if they can prove that they've been rejected by N banks. Which is a start, I suppose.

Banks have basically become an extension of law enforcement, tax collectors, anti-terrorist operations, and morality police. Which is ironic, given how many banks brazenly break laws on the regular, how absolutely depraved parties with bankers are, etc. They're hardly paragons of virtue. Yet they get to gatekeep "virtue".

replies(7): >>44002984 #>>44003169 #>>44003339 #>>44005602 #>>44008125 #>>44008609 #>>44010737 #
1. FrustratedMonky ◴[] No.44008125[source]
"legalized prostitution"

If legal, then why do banks have a problem offering an account. No risk of a bad actor, because it is legal.

It would be like a small business or contractor.

replies(1): >>44008228 #
2. ativzzz ◴[] No.44008228[source]
Probably because it's one of those industries where legalizing it still attracts a large enough black market (human trafficking is a huge thing) that it's easier to just blanket ban it than try to separate the legal from the illegal