←back to thread

97 points surprisetalk | 5 comments | | HN request time: 0.552s | source
Show context
neonnoodle ◴[] No.44005752[source]
APRIL 1805

NAPOLEON IS MASTER OF EUROPE.

ONLY THE BRITISH FLEET STANDS BEFORE HIM.

OCEANS ARE NOW BATTLEFIELDS.

replies(6): >>44005940 #>>44005972 #>>44006024 #>>44006126 #>>44006315 #>>44007880 #
alabastervlog ◴[] No.44005940[source]
1) God damn that movie is so good.

2) I think part of why it stands out so much is that there are incredibly few excellently-made age of sail war films. A few of the black & white and early color era ones are pretty good (The Sea Hawk and such) but those are pretty different in tone. Master and Commander is very nearly unique. You have to switch over to sci fi (Star Trek, maybe Forbidden Planet) to scratch a similar itch. If you want specifically age of sail, with that structure and tone (war, edge-of-civilization exploration with a ship), your options are very limited.

3) I have discovered only very-belatedly that Peter Weir is one of my favorite directors. I had no idea for the longest time that the same guy did The Mosquito Coast, Master and Commander, The Year of Living Dangerously, Dead Poet's Society, Witness, and The Truman Show. Dude just knocked out one quietly-great movie after another, across multiple genres. I've gone back and picked up some others (Gallipoli, The Cars that Ate Paris) and have yet to be disappointed. The remainder of his all-too-short catalogue is high up my to-watch list. I've seen zero duds from him so far.

replies(3): >>44006388 #>>44006628 #>>44007198 #
1. kridsdale3 ◴[] No.44007198[source]
I have always desperately wanted a Star Wars movie that is essentially nothing more than Master and Commander.

No magical beings, no one-in-a-trillion mega-celebrities. Just professionals doing their jobs within the Navy and the adventures they had as mortal, skilled, men.

What are the TIE Pilots talking about off-shift, how does the Captain feel about the new mission priorities?

Andor is closest we've had to seeing this POV.

replies(4): >>44007291 #>>44008095 #>>44010016 #>>44010734 #
2. alabastervlog ◴[] No.44007291[source]
Yeah, kind of what Lower Decks (the show, and for that matter also the episode "Lower Decks") is to Star Trek, but not comedy. Andor is indeed the closest I know of to that, though you see little touches of similar things in some episodes of The Mandalorian and the Clone Wars cartoon (though of course that one's also full of the "magical beings")
3. kryogen1c ◴[] No.44008095[source]
> Just professionals doing their jobs

This is one of the reasons I love Rogue One. There is a desperation that permeates the film that culminates into the titanic final scene

4. xeonmc ◴[] No.44010016[source]
If Peter Jackson had followed through with Temeraire I think it’d be right up your alley.
5. arzig ◴[] No.44010734[source]
I feel like there have been rumblings of an honor Harrington by David Weber movie for decades at this point. It it may just not happen.