←back to thread

1167 points jbredeche | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.414s | source
Show context
ecshafer ◴[] No.43998721[source]
As a father, the idea of being told my 1 week old baby is going to die would be my worst nightmare. The fact these doctors and scientists saved this childs life is a monument to modern medical science. This is absolutely insane. Hopefully the child doesnt need a liver transplant, but this is a great leap forward.
replies(3): >>43999051 #>>43999602 #>>44000589 #
alexashka[dead post] ◴[] No.44000589[source]
[flagged]
silver_silver ◴[] No.44000660[source]
What an insanely callous and shallow take. I don’t even know where to start. You’re trying to claim the moral high ground by complaining that a privileged child didn’t suffer and die? Do you even understand the point of reducing poverty?
replies(2): >>44000742 #>>44001269 #
cayley_graph ◴[] No.44000742[source]
An absolutely terrible and tone-deaf way to phrase that thought, but the fact of the matter is that most of the world (you and I included, in all likelihood) will not get access to this sort of thing in our lifetimes. Not because modern medicine won't have been there yet, but because our lives (and those of our children) are simply seen as being worth significantly less than a rich person's desire to become richer.

How many people can even afford to get multiple opinions for a weird lump on their back? Or go to the dentist for a strange toothache? How many people can afford to get consistent exercise and eat healthy? How many lives would be saved or at least massively bettered? We already have the means to extend the life expectancy of the average person, and it's not being used. Obviously this is a wonderful medical advance, but it's depressing to wonder who it's for.

replies(4): >>44001312 #>>44001371 #>>44001374 #>>44005151 #
1. piloto_ciego ◴[] No.44001312[source]
So obviously we should not be excited about it? Lose me with that noise.
replies(1): >>44001325 #
2. cayley_graph ◴[] No.44001325[source]
Do point out where that was said, and I will be happy to correct it! It's important to have nuanced opinions and discussions about things.