←back to thread

437 points Vinnl | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.723s | source
Show context
isaacremuant ◴[] No.43994007[source]
Everything tends to optimize to benefit the rich. Just like tax incentives on expensive electric vehicles.

Of course every other metric section is beaming but the one about affecting lower income is "it's too early to tell".

It's not fair economics or policy making if it always skews one way. It's like "carbon tax to force people not to fly or move, while elite private planes are essential".

replies(2): >>43995489 #>>43997022 #
1. Ajedi32 ◴[] No.43995489[source]
> It's not fair economics

I think you have a distorted sense of what fairness is. Charging the same price to the rich that you charge to the poor for the same service is fair. Charging different prices would be unfair.

Charity/philanthropy is a good thing, because human life is inherently valuable, but it's not a matter of fairness. People don't have an inherent right to benefit from the labor or ingenuity of others.

replies(1): >>44000553 #
2. isaacremuant ◴[] No.44000553[source]
> think you have a distorted sense of what fairness is. Charging the same price to the rich that you charge to the poor for the same service is fair. Charging different prices would be unfair.

Nice strawman. No. Charging for something that changes behavior in the poor but not in the rich because it's an exclusinary device is definitely not fair. I also didn't suggest different prices but simply not doing exclusion via money or taxation, which doesn't affect the rich.

> Charity/philanthropy is a good thing, because human life is inherently valuable, but it's not a matter of fairness. People don't have an inherent right to benefit from the labor or ingenuity of others.

What are you on about? I'm sorry to tell you but the likes of corporate magnates and rich politicians don't create more value just bend the rules to stay on top. It's easy to throw money at things to create more money when you have it. When you can put your capital in a tax haven and the rubble pays it in full.

Next time you come with inspired strawmen takes, prep a bit.