←back to thread

848 points thefilmore | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.001s | source
Show context
bandrami ◴[] No.43969975[source]
Pretty cool that Linus Torvalds invented a completely distributed version control system and 20 years later we all use it to store our code in a single place.
replies(29): >>43969999 #>>43970002 #>>43970008 #>>43970018 #>>43970019 #>>43970028 #>>43970031 #>>43970032 #>>43970036 #>>43970037 #>>43970142 #>>43970154 #>>43970198 #>>43970282 #>>43970314 #>>43970343 #>>43970418 #>>43970419 #>>43970431 #>>43970434 #>>43970451 #>>43970472 #>>43970541 #>>43970904 #>>43971268 #>>43971299 #>>43971387 #>>43971586 #>>43988717 #
SCdF ◴[] No.43970018[source]
I get what you're saying, but tbf hosting on github doesn't (yet!) box you out of just moving back to that system. It's still just git. It's still distributed, in the sense that if github goes down you could still generate patches and email them around, and then push back to github when it's back.

Everything surrounding code: issues, CICD, etc, is obviously another story. But it's not a story that is answered by distributed git either. (though I would love a good issue tracking system that is done entirely inside git)

replies(9): >>43970039 #>>43970120 #>>43970143 #>>43970151 #>>43970180 #>>43970299 #>>43970301 #>>43970480 #>>43970514 #
sshine ◴[] No.43970143[source]
> if github goes down you could still generate patches and email them around, and then push back to github when it's back.

You could, but generally people can’t. They learn a set of narrow workflows and never explore beyond. GitHub use translates into GitLab use, but not into general git use workout a central repository.

> Everything surrounding code: issues, CICD, etc, is obviously another story. But it's not a story that is answered by distributed git either. (though I would love a good issue tracking system that is done entirely inside git)

Radicle offers one. CLI-based, too.

replies(4): >>43970191 #>>43970214 #>>43970429 #>>43970525 #
1. laserbeam ◴[] No.43970525[source]
> You could, but generally people can’t. They learn a set of narrow workflows and never explore beyond.

The point is you CAN. Joe can in theory do it, and Steve can make an alternative piece of software to do it for Joe. In most other centralized places (like social media), you CANNOT. Joe cannot take his data off of Facebook and interact with it outside of the platform or move it to another platform.