←back to thread

451 points croes | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.001s | source
Show context
jhaile ◴[] No.43964361[source]
One aspect that I feel is ignored by the comments here is the geo-political forces at work. If the US takes the position that LLMs can't use copyrighted work or has to compensate all copyright holders – other countries (e.g. China) will not follow suit. This will mean that US LLM companies will either fall behind or be too expensive. Which means China and other countries will probably surge ahead in AI, at least in terms of how useful the AI is.

That is not to say that we shouldn't do the right thing regardless, but I do think there is a feeling of "who is going to rule the world in the future?" tha underlies governmental decision-making on how much to regulate AI.

replies(10): >>43964511 #>>43964513 #>>43964544 #>>43964546 #>>43964647 #>>43964799 #>>43965877 #>>43966756 #>>43969913 #>>43974233 #
therouwboat ◴[] No.43964544[source]
If AI is so important, maybe it should be owned by the government and free to use for all citizens.
replies(1): >>43964591 #
pc86 ◴[] No.43964591[source]
Name two non-military things that the government owns and aren't complete dumpster fires that barely do the thing they're supposed to do.

Even (especially?) the military is a dumpster fire but it's at least very good at doing what it exists to do.

replies(10): >>43964650 #>>43964655 #>>43964684 #>>43964718 #>>43964753 #>>43964773 #>>43964792 #>>43964900 #>>43965196 #>>43969002 #
1. azemetre ◴[] No.43964773{3}[source]
Medicaid, Medicare, and Social Security are all three programs that have massive approval from US citizens.

Even saying the military is a dumpster fire isn't accurate. The military has led trillions of dollars worth of extraction for the wealthy and elite across the globe.

In no sane world can you say that the ability to protect GLOBAL shipping lanes as a failure. That one service alone has probably paid for itself thousands of times.

We aren't even talking about things like public education (high school education use to be privatized and something only the elites enjoyed 100 years ago; yes public high school education isn't even 100 years old) or libraries or public parks.

---

I really don't understand this "gobermint iz bad" meme you see in tech circles.

I get more out of my taxes compared to equivalent corporate bills that it's laughable.

Government is comprised of people and the last 50 years has been the government mostly giving money and establishing programs to the small cohorts that have been hoarding all the wealth. Somehow this is never an issue with the government however.

Also never understand the arguments from these types either because if you think the government is bad then you should want it to be better. Better mostly meaning having more money to redistribute and more personal to run programs, but it's never about these things. It's always attacking the government to make it worse at the expense of the people.