←back to thread

611 points LorenDB | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.198s | source
Show context
dvratil ◴[] No.43908097[source]
The one thing that sold me on Rust (going from C++) was that there is a single way errors are propagated: the Result type. No need to bother with exceptions, functions returning bool, functions returning 0 on success, functions returning 0 on error, functions returning -1 on error, functions returning negative errno on error, functions taking optional pointer to bool to indicate error (optionally), functions taking reference to std::error_code to set an error (and having an overload with the same name that throws an exception on error if you forget to pass the std::error_code)...I understand there's 30 years of history, but it still is annoying, that even the standard library is not consistent (or striving for consistency).

Then you top it on with `?` shortcut and the functional interface of Result and suddenly error handling becomes fun and easy to deal with, rather than just "return false" with a "TODO: figure out error handling".

replies(24): >>43908133 #>>43908158 #>>43908212 #>>43908219 #>>43908294 #>>43908381 #>>43908419 #>>43908540 #>>43908623 #>>43908682 #>>43908981 #>>43909007 #>>43909117 #>>43909521 #>>43910388 #>>43912855 #>>43912904 #>>43913484 #>>43913794 #>>43914062 #>>43914514 #>>43917029 #>>43922951 #>>43924618 #
ryandrake ◴[] No.43909521[source]
Error handling and propagation is one of those things I found the most irritating and struggled[1] with the most as I learned Rust, and to be honest, I'm still not sure I understand or like Rust's way. Decades of C++ and Python has strongly biased me towards the try/except pattern.

1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41543183

replies(2): >>43909625 #>>43911068 #
1. skrtskrt ◴[] No.43909625[source]
there are answers in the thread you linked that show how easy and clean the error handling can be.

it can look just like a more-efficient `except` clauses with all the safety, clarity, and convenience that enums provide.

Here's an example:

* Implementing an error type with enums: https://git.deuxfleurs.fr/Deuxfleurs/garage/src/branch/main/... * Which derives from a more general error type with even more helpful enums: https://git.deuxfleurs.fr/Deuxfleurs/garage/src/branch/main/... * then some straightforward handling of the error: https://git.deuxfleurs.fr/Deuxfleurs/garage/src/branch/main/...