←back to thread

The Death of Daydreaming

(www.afterbabel.com)
707 points isolli | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
bhouston ◴[] No.43896107[source]
I find that daydreaming is absolutely critical for coming up with good strategies. Otherwise I can default to just do the next obvious thing, which isn't always the most strategic if you can take in the full picture, or at least consider alternatives well.

The two ways I get to strategic reflection are really:

- Doing lego. I find thhat doing lego is actually really good at helping me consolidate thoughts and ideas. It takes up just enough mental energy to not get bored, but it lets me think about things with an unstressed mind.

- Walks. The other way to generate new perspectives is to take a walk at lunch though non-interesting territory. I really do not find walks in a busy downtown to be relaxing, too much activity intruding on me to actually be low stress, but if it is in a forest or even just a long parkway that works for me.

The absolute worst way to come up with new ideas is in front of my computer trying to work. Good for doing the next obvious thing, but really hard to think outside of the box.

You really do need a mix of the two, otherwise you are either doing the obvious or never actually doing anything.

replies(14): >>43896273 #>>43896336 #>>43896431 #>>43896547 #>>43896590 #>>43896600 #>>43896616 #>>43896773 #>>43896878 #>>43897002 #>>43897471 #>>43897689 #>>43897789 #>>43908552 #
whywhywhywhy ◴[] No.43896273[source]
Sitting on public transport looking out of the window not your phone and listening to music is ok but probably not podcasts.

Also showers are very good for the right state of mind.

replies(5): >>43896311 #>>43896369 #>>43896838 #>>43896959 #>>43897389 #
SirFatty ◴[] No.43896369[source]
The shower, every time. No idea what the difference is if I stand in the shower or sit on the couch in my living room. Sometimes I end up looking like a prune.
replies(7): >>43896473 #>>43896511 #>>43896597 #>>43896715 #>>43896764 #>>43896891 #>>43902762 #
echelon ◴[] No.43896891[source]
This has been my experience for optimal creativity tasks:

- Best: walks, running, walking in circles, walking in circles talking over the phone (1:1 planning), walking in circles talking out loud to myself

- Good: showers, daydreaming in place, daydreaming on trips where I'm not driving, "pair program" white boarding with one other (exceptional) person

- Okay: white boarding by myself, trying to put ideas to pen and paper by myself, meetings with the right people in a physical space

- Bad: at the computer, on the phone, walking or running to podcasts, walking or running to the wrong type of music, video conference meetings, and generally all other meetings

- What are you even doing: YouTube, Netflix, or podcasts on in the background at any level

replies(1): >>43897355 #
1. klabb3 ◴[] No.43897355[source]
I agree but what is the root cause? Which things are generally bad for the brain? Because if it was social, meetings would be good. And if it’s reality escape, going to the movies would be bad.
replies(1): >>43898573 #
2. echelon ◴[] No.43898573[source]
Perhaps it's in putting the brain in a place where the body is on autopilot and the verbal / spatial centers of the brain can be free to wander in and out of focus.

Podcasts kill this mode for me, so you can't have the brain thinking about other people's thoughts or words.

Playing a video game doesn't work, so I think your spatial thinking has to be free too.

It's as if distracting the brain's non-verbal/spatial modes or burning some amount of calories from those centers gives the "thinking" parts of the brain some "alone time". That's an incredibly non-scientific and unserious hypothesis though.