←back to thread

Design for 3D-Printing

(blog.rahix.de)
837 points q3k | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.223s | source
Show context
hengheng ◴[] No.43888730[source]
Great article. This is all above the skill level of the average part on thingiverse or printables, but the good parts on there are going to follow similar ideas. Love the mouse ears, press-fit holes and step-by-step alignment of layers to build impossible bridges.

Notably, in fusion 360 this would all be designed in "plastics" mode, and yet that mode is oblivious to whether the part is printed or moulded. I wonder if any CAD engine can do "production-aware design" that constrains design to the capabilities of standardized machines, e.g. keeping a metal part 3-d millable. I've seen strict design rule enforcement with PCBs, and I have seen sheet metal macros, but nothing for general mechanical CAD.

replies(5): >>43889138 #>>43890421 #>>43890844 #>>43891414 #>>43892106 #
digdugdirk ◴[] No.43889138[source]
I've investigated this space, and I'm not entirely sure its even a desired goal from the perspective of a mechanical designer. The benefit tends to be for smaller aspects (ensuring hole sizes are appropriate for the desired thread, or that holes aren't too close to a bend line on a sheet metal part, etc) but the final design of a 3d part is so non-deterministic, and the variety of manufacturing methods are so varied and unique, it might just cause more issues than benefits.
replies(3): >>43890527 #>>43891027 #>>43895363 #
1. sitkack ◴[] No.43895363[source]
I use many of these techniques and have modules in openscad to create build orientation aware parts and have for years. You can be less not entirely sure, because many people already do this.