Design for 3D-Printing

This looks so good. I’ve gotten into 3D printing in the past six months with an A1 Mini. I initially bought it intending solely to do creative projects with my kid, but I’ve been surprised to find myself getting deeper into printing functional parts. I recently printed a 6” server rack for a GLi.net Beryl and Apple TV for travel, from a combination of pre-designed and self-designed parts.

3D printing as a pursuit can be time-consuming - there’s always a risk with these things that you take them on as a dilettante and they end up gathering dust in a corner. I initially scraped by with some middling Blender skills (leaning into non-destructive operations where possible), but that is far from ideal - you really do need CAD. But to anyone considering jumping in, I would say: if you get an A1 (get the full size, not the Mini) and use Claude to write your parametric OpenSCAD scripts, the time commitment is such that you can _just about_ indulge in this hobby as a dilettante - eg, as a project for your kids. Without LLMs, I think it would be too much of a commitment unless you’re really dedicated, or already have CAD skills.

Anyway, gonna go read this in full.

Side bar... There are a lot of people who are going to use LLMs to try to do 3D modeling stuff and who are going to hit a wall with it really, really fast. Mechanical design really is a completely different discipline that is very poorly abstractable in the particular way that software engineers are used to.

I disagree. My co-worker is an industrial designer and uses Rhino as his day to day CAD tool of choice. I was delighted to see that it translates everything you do to a command line syntax and there's also Python integration. We did some simple tests the other week and you can actually prototype reasonably well by instructing an LLM to generate the Python code that creates the models. It still requires fine tuning but seems like a similar multiplier like using LLMs for programming to get the boring boilerplate out of the way.

I'd say a good designer will at least 2x, probably 5x. We are preparing to test with students next semester to see how non-experts profit from this.