←back to thread

Design for 3D-Printing

(blog.rahix.de)
837 points q3k | 8 comments | | HN request time: 0.001s | source | bottom
Show context
pclark ◴[] No.43889062[source]
I know they get a lot of hate in the HN community but my Bambu Labs P1S is mind blowing. It’s so easy to use I print 100x more than with my old Ender. It’s motivated me to learn Fusion360 … i’m actually printing droids for my kids to color this very minute.
replies(6): >>43889113 #>>43889193 #>>43889230 #>>43891351 #>>43894530 #>>43903614 #
1. zoky ◴[] No.43889230[source]
I know two people with that exact model of 3D printer. Both printers are routinely out of commission for weeks on end due to some failure that the owners lack either the technical expertise to diagnose and fix or the desire to pay exorbitant prices for proprietary replacement parts to fix (or both). Meanwhile my Ender 5 is always chugging along, and is never out of commission for more than a day or two while awaiting replacement parts from Amazon that cost between a few cents and up to maybe $20 each.

I don’t actually think Bambu makes unreliable printers; to the contrary, they are excellent machines that, if anything, are much more reliable on the whole than Creality. But they’re kind of like sports cars, in that their target market is either people who want something fast and flashy and are willing to throw money at any problems to make them go away, or for technical types who want something they can take out on the track and don’t mind wrenching their own machines. The problem is that Bambu printers are marketed and touted as being great for beginners, and while they certainly make it easy to get into 3D printing for nontechnical people, I think most of them will end up ultimately being disappointed at either the lack of customization they allow or amount of time, effort, and money required to diagnose and fix them when something goes wrong.

replies(5): >>43889882 #>>43889912 #>>43890041 #>>43892086 #>>43893378 #
2. pclark ◴[] No.43889882[source]
as I said, as a Bambu owner, i’m really impressed with mine and highly recommend them to others.
3. Max-q ◴[] No.43889912[source]
I think that conclusion is wrong, they are absolutely for beginners. No bed leveling. Lidar scan of first layer. Filament sensors. Good software. Enders are sold to beginners but you actually need to be an expert to get good results and keep them running.
4. vjvjvjvjghv ◴[] No.43890041[source]
My Bambu A1 just works. I had an Ender 3 before and it almost killed my interest in 3d printing because my prints constantly failed. I don’t see a path where the A1 could disappoint me.
5. lttlrck ◴[] No.43892086[source]
My biggest complaint is that the filament RFID spec is closed.

BBL parts are not very expensive and their support is stellar. Of course if they go bankrupt we'll be high and dry.

Prior to my two A1s I spent more time, and more money in parts, mucking about with the printers, modifying and calibrating, tweaking Klipper than getting anything done.

replies(1): >>43896778 #
6. Vespasian ◴[] No.43893378[source]
We had no issues with our bambu whatsoever. It's a great machine that does exactly what it advertised to do.

It's not magic and faces the same limitations as all other 3D-priters but it's execution is top notch. I can't remember a single instance where I felt the need to change the printer settings in the slicer besides selecting one of the presets.

Our filament purchases went up by at aleast an order of magnitude and new members to our club get the hang of it really quick.y

7. gaudystead ◴[] No.43896778[source]
One of the biggest selling points for me upgrading to an X1C was for similar reasons... I wanted more time to work _with_ the machine, not work _on_ the machine (if that makes sense).
replies(1): >>43897065 #
8. baq ◴[] No.43897065{3}[source]
I've seen this put as '3d printing hobby' vs '3d printer hobby'.