←back to thread

254 points perihelions | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
47282847 ◴[] No.43810954[source]
It’s interesting to muse about the larger picture here. What is it that makes autism so dangerous? To me it looks like part of an almost spiritual war against empathy/compassion by traumatized individuals trying to fight their own Jungian Shadow.
replies(17): >>43810993 #>>43811031 #>>43811124 #>>43811131 #>>43811210 #>>43811523 #>>43811563 #>>43812343 #>>43813804 #>>43816351 #>>43816599 #>>43816739 #>>43816746 #>>43817086 #>>43818486 #>>43825472 #>>43866752 #
rayiner ◴[] No.43816351[source]
Fixing diseases and abnormalities in humans is empathy and compassion.
replies(4): >>43816529 #>>43817406 #>>43817454 #>>43825922 #
MattGrommes ◴[] No.43817406[source]
The problem is not fixing diseases. The problem is what is defined as a disease or abnormality. The problem is people who are clearly choosing abnormalities based on politics, power grabs, and anti-science rhetoric.
replies(1): >>43817685 #
rayiner ◴[] No.43817685[source]
Science and medicine is what has defined autism as a disease or abnormality. Science and medicine are telling us that the rates of these diseases are growing dramatically, for decades now.

RFK isn’t the one who made autism concern happen. My three year old’s teacher asked us to get him tested with the county for autism. It’s a very common thing parents are dealing with these days. I’d argue that what you’re saying is exactly backward. The medical community has defined a lot of normal behavior as autism.

Now, I agree RFK’s views on what’s causing autism are anti-scientific, and I doubt he’ll be able to figure out what’s causing it. But RFK has a platform because the medical community has diagnosed all these kids as autistic but doesn’t have an explanation for what’s causing it. So looks like RFK fill the void.

replies(3): >>43818125 #>>43818598 #>>43822045 #
Seb-C ◴[] No.43822045[source]
It is well understood already that the number of autistic people is not actually increasing. What is increasing is our understanding of it and the number of diagnostics.

The fact that high functioning people like Asperger got merged with it and changed to a spectrum is precisely science at work, achieving to improve our understanding of the phenomenon. We previously believed that only the extreme cases were autistic, but we now understand that this limit was arbitrary and wrong, because autism is a broader spectrum of people with a wide range of possible characteristics.

Autism is not a disease, it's a neurodivergence, and it is very important to understand that autistic people are not broken, but simply function differently. The proof being that outside of a minority of extreme cases, autistic people does not have issues communicating or socializing with other autistic people.

Trying to categorize people as "normal" and "abnormal" and then pretending to "fix" the abnormal ones is dangerous and drifts towards eugenism, because there is not a single definition of normal, and there is probably not a single person on earth that is "normal".

If 97% of the population was autistic, then autistic people would not have any issues. The remaining 3% of what is currently considered neurotypical would be the ones having difficulties socializing, communicating and experiencing severe anxieties and psychological problems due to it.

This is why the solution is not to "fix" autism, but to help them find an environment where they can strive, be understood and live comfortably.

replies(1): >>43826117 #
TeaBrain ◴[] No.43826117[source]
>It is well understood already that the number of autistic people is not actually increasing. What is increasing is our understanding of it and the number of diagnostics.

I see this idea thrown around whenever this topic is brought up, but this is just a contemporary opinion of certain researchers and science commentators. It is both unprovable and unfalsifiable.

>Autism is not a disease, it's a neurodivergence, and it is very important to understand that autistic people are not broken, but simply function differently.

A teacher I had in high school has an adult child with severe autism who is still living with her, because he can't take care of himself. He's not simply functioning differently, nor is anyone else that has the condition so severely that they can't perform any job.

replies(1): >>43826709 #
sureglymop ◴[] No.43826709[source]
Please read through this page shared here on HN a few days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43813441
replies(3): >>43826957 #>>43828653 #>>43828827 #
1. ◴[] No.43828653{3}[source]