←back to thread

369 points zeech | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.544s | source
Show context
anenefan ◴[] No.43800302[source]
My younger bro is convinced phones are eavesdropping on conversations and got particularly paranoid (I thought) a year or so back in regard to talking in earshot of his phone.

His evidence is empirical - Apparently he gets pretty high with friends and shit talks - but when when the search started to suggest some pretty way out things along the same lines, he landed that their conversations weren't private any more.

So I have an understanding of how much tracking is going on so I pressed him on that. But he assured me it was stuff he would not even bother to look up in a clearer mindset and of course smoking recreationally for a very long time knows not to go near some tools that could land himself trouble or awkward explanations. That's probably true he says a lot of stuff that a half decent search would put him straight. In the end I just figured loose permissions of one of the many apps he's installed and that's how they (the app) make their money, selling illegally obtained data to more legal sources.

Permissions are the problem with android phones - there needs to be a specific install route for users, one that the app starts asking for things it should not need have access to, the installer refuses to install and suggests the user look for something better. Camera apps for example really don't need access to communication channels, if it's updates it's need, it can ask - one time access.

replies(6): >>43800320 #>>43800370 #>>43800373 #>>43800381 #>>43800436 #>>43805325 #
edgyquant ◴[] No.43800381[source]
He’s right and everyone knows it. It's pretty blatant and there have been lawsuits settle rather than go to a trial that would surely reveal the extent to which this thing that’s obviously happening is happening

https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/apple-siri-priva...

replies(1): >>43800633 #
simonw ◴[] No.43800633[source]
I attempted to debunk that one here (an admittedly impossible task but I can't help myself trying): https://simonwillison.net/2025/Jan/2/they-spy-on-you-but-not...
replies(2): >>43801032 #>>43801107 #
1. alganet ◴[] No.43801107[source]
It is irrelevant. The suggestion that spying is for advertisement makes no difference.

That idea only exists to create fake two-dimensional anti-capilist rethoric, which is a rethoric easier to put down than the fact that privacy does not exist anymore.

So, I am supposed to do this. To "correct you" and look very lunatic.

It serves, however, a very specific goal. First, it cannot be copied en masse. If this behavior is copied (even as a meme), it implies doom to the more easier to defeat anti-capitalist rethoric and the birth of a true 3D anti-capitalist rethoric. It can only be mocked (smoking guy pointing to a conspiracy board), but that mockery is getting real serious real fast now.

Can I dive deeper into the mechanics of how this is gonna go?

We had so many chances, of doing good. You all had so many chances.