←back to thread

377 points NaOH | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.24s | source
Show context
HanClinto ◴[] No.43793725[source]
This is so needed. This was a very encouraging article.

"Being a fan is all about bringing the enthusiasm. It’s being a champion of possibility. It’s believing in someone. And it’s contagious. When you’re around someone who is super excited about something, it washes over you. It feels good. You can’t help but want to bring the enthusiasm, too."

Stands in contrast to the Hemingway quote: "Critics are men who watch a battle from a high place then come down and shoot the survivors."

It feels socially safe, easy, and destructive to be a critic.

I'd rather be a fan.

replies(15): >>43793906 #>>43794073 #>>43794235 #>>43794376 #>>43794398 #>>43797022 #>>43797229 #>>43797763 #>>43797960 #>>43798310 #>>43798439 #>>43800608 #>>43801652 #>>43801753 #>>43801843 #
pjc50 ◴[] No.43793906[source]
Yes, but .. there is no worse critic than a scorned fan. There's a lot of fandoms all around the world, and while they're mostly harmless fun the edges can get weird and dangerous. Or when fandoms collide.
replies(1): >>43794109 #
HanClinto ◴[] No.43794109[source]
Not entirely sure what you mean. Care to expound?

Are you talking about people who act out on their fandom by criticizing others? "Oh I'm a fan of X, therefore I'm a vocal critic of Y". I agree that such things are toxic -- fandom doesn't need to be a polemic.

I want to cultivate the kind of fandom that builds up without feeling a need to tear down others.

replies(3): >>43794386 #>>43794403 #>>43794422 #
1. lukan ◴[] No.43794386[source]
I rather think he or she means gamers for example, who send out death threats, because the developers introduced a new thing they don't like.