←back to thread

108 points sohkamyung | 4 comments | | HN request time: 2.089s | source
Show context
vunderba ◴[] No.43738065[source]
Joplin is really nice feature-wise but the last time I looked at it a few years back I absolutely HATED the way that it structured your notes.

The way it worked was that they stored new/existing notes in an SQLite table with UUIDs. This of course makes it very difficult to use bash tools, other IDEs, etc. to work with your notes after Joplin has ingested them.

Further the related media was renamed "UUID.<related extension>" which were stored in `~/.config/joplin-desktop/resources`.

Compare this to apps like VS Code / Obsidian / Logseq (also open source) which don't mess with your markdown file organization. You can just point them to a root folder and they'll work natively with your markdown files. No syncing required.

replies(4): >>43750582 #>>43750869 #>>43752058 #>>43756015 #
darkmuck ◴[] No.43750869[source]
I'm with you 100%. I wish there was an OSS tool that was like Obsidian and cross-platform (no cloud hosting required). Logseq is the closest but the markdown standard isn't fully supported, and they add a lot of custom syntax/metadata.
replies(3): >>43751781 #>>43752628 #>>43777018 #
1. terminalgravity ◴[] No.43751781[source]
You said “like Obsidian”. Which parts of Obsidian are most important for you
replies(1): >>43753251 #
2. darkmuck ◴[] No.43753251[source]
- Apps for, at least, windows and android.

- Storage of files in a folder that can be seen by the OS to allow sync by something like syncthing

- Moderately good UI (nice to have: live preview of markdown)

- Core features not behind a paywall (e.g. siyuan can't sync, notenook missing important features)

- Nice to have: push notifications for tasks/reminders

replies(1): >>43753932 #
3. celsius1414 ◴[] No.43753932[source]
I keep thinking about how much feature lists like this could be matched by the Finder/File Explorer and my favorite text editor.
replies(1): >>43754201 #
4. darkmuck ◴[] No.43754201{3}[source]
Yes of course but not on android. Also I'd prefer the same app/experience across platforms.