←back to thread

207 points gnabgib | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.206s | source
Show context
imiric ◴[] No.43748550[source]
Chilling. Governments weaponizing information they have on citizens is textbook dystopian. The lack of oversight on social media platforms that allows this to happen is incompetence at best, and complicity at worst.

As more governments slip into autocracies, similar scenarios are likely happening in other countries as well, and we just don't know about it. The fact that US social media platforms are operated by people supportive of an aspiring autocrat should be a red flag for anyone still using them. Especially for citizens of the US, where the line between the government and corporations gets thinner by the day.

These are truly bizarre and frightening times for anyone outside of this system.

replies(4): >>43748820 #>>43748857 #>>43750167 #>>43751495 #
CGamesPlay ◴[] No.43748857[source]
> The lack of oversight on social media platforms that allows this to happen is incompetence at best, and complicity at worst.

The social media platforms are supposed to what? Be a foil to the governments? Replace the government? Be a foil to the governments you don't like? It's unclear what you think the ideal here is.

replies(2): >>43749825 #>>43749941 #
imiric ◴[] No.43749941[source]
TFA mentions 4 recommendations that social media platforms can implement to prevent the abuse of their users. These aren't even political, but pertain to the practice of doxxing in general.

And like a sibling comment mentioned, companies should operate separately from governments. When that separation is blurred the checks and balances that are supposed to be in place in order to keep companies from abusing people, and from being an extension for governments to do the same, are just gone. At that point the country becomes a corporatocracy, serving the interests of companies rather than citizens.

The US has arguably functioned like this for decades, but when there are literal businessmen in power this is more evident than ever before. It's how you get scenarios of presidents manipulating the economy for their and their cronies' benefit. The next step is complete authoritarianism where companies are government puppets, where the spread of and access to information is tightly controlled and sprinkled with their own propaganda in order to keep megalomaniacs in power, and where any dissidence is squashed before it has the chance to spread. This is how you get China, Russia, and any government that aspires to that formula.

It's crazy that this needs explanation, or that it's a controversial line of thought.

replies(2): >>43750502 #>>43750638 #
1. seanhunter ◴[] No.43750502[source]
It’s not practical to think that companies can operate separately from governments and indeed I think they should not. We want companies to be subject to the law. That means if governments bring something like a subpoena or other court order to the company, the company should comply.

Well for jurisdictions where the government weaponizes the justice system that means the company either has to choose not to do business there or to bend the knee..