←back to thread

Pope Francis has died

(www.reuters.com)
916 points phillipharris | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.21s | source
Show context
7bit ◴[] No.43750249[source]
@tomhow

I understand the intention behind keeping the thread respectful, especially in the context of someone’s death. That said, I find it difficult to fully separate reflections on Pope Francis from reflections on the institution he led. The papacy is not just a personal role—it is deeply representative of the Catholic Church as an institution, with all the historical and present-day weight that carries.

It also stands out to me that similar moderation reminders don't usually appear in threads about other public figures. That gives the impression that this topic is being treated as more sensitive or "untouchable" than others, and I think it's fair to question why that is.

I'm all for thoughtful conversation, but part of that includes being able to engage critically with the institutions and roles that public figures embody—even in moments like this.

replies(2): >>43750319 #>>43750600 #
1. heresie-dabord ◴[] No.43750319[source]
> similar moderation reminders don't usually appear in threads about other public figures.

Friend, this is not true. "dang" himself has often exhorted posters in this same manner and language when a notable death may attract inconsiderate commentary.

See the search link provided by tomhow in this branch of the same discussion:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43749405#43750046