Not every "prominent elder" deserves respect. Certainly not on the basis that men in a smoke filled room elected them the infallible avatar of a God that most people don't even believe in. People are in awe of this latest Pope because his morals were essentially
normal and not medieval. The Pope was just a guy in a robe.
The world would be much better off if we listened to scientists and scholars - people who at least earned the authority with which they speak - the way we listen to priests.