←back to thread

174 points Philpax | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.208s | source
Show context
dcchambers ◴[] No.43720006[source]
And in 30 years it will be another 30 years away.

LLMs are so incredibly useful and powerful but they will NEVER be AGI. I actually wonder if the success of (and subsequent obsession with) LLMs is putting true AGI further out of reach. All that these AI companies see are the $$$. When the biggest "AI Research Labs" like OpenAI shifted to product-izing their LLM offerings I think the writing was on the wall that they don't actually care about finding AGI.

replies(3): >>43720042 #>>43720073 #>>43721975 #
thomasahle ◴[] No.43720042[source]
People will keep improving LLMs, and by the time they are AGI (less than 30 years), you will say, "Well, these are no longer LLMs."
replies(6): >>43720091 #>>43720108 #>>43720115 #>>43720202 #>>43720341 #>>43721154 #
__MatrixMan__ ◴[] No.43720115[source]
What the hell is general intelligence anyway? People seem to think it means human-like intelligence, but I can't imagine we have any good reason to believe that our kinds of intelligence constitute all possible kinds of intelligence--which, from the words, must be what "general" intelligence means.

It seems like even if it's possible to achieve GI, artificial or otherwise, you'd never be able to know for sure that thats what you've done. It's not exactly "useful benchmark" material.

replies(3): >>43720234 #>>43720327 #>>43721422 #
thomasahle ◴[] No.43720327[source]
> What the hell is general intelligence anyway?

OpenAI used to define it as "a highly autonomous system that outperforms humans at most economically valuable work."

Now they used a Level 1-5 scale: https://briansolis.com/2024/08/ainsights-openai-defines-five...

So we can say AGI is "AI that can do the work of Organizations":

> These “Organizations” can manage and execute all functions of a business, surpassing traditional human-based operations in terms of efficiency and productivity. This stage represents the pinnacle of AI development, where AI can autonomously run complex organizational structures.

replies(4): >>43721203 #>>43722670 #>>43722911 #>>43742001 #
1. __MatrixMan__ ◴[] No.43742001[source]
That's a silly definition, even if somebody with a lot of money wrote it. Organizations can do more than individuals for the same reason that an M4 can do more than a Pentium 4--it's a difference in degree.

Generality is about differences in kind. Like how my drill press can do things that an M4 can't. How could you ever know that your kinds of intelligence are all of them?