←back to thread

863 points IdealeZahlen | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.877s | source
Show context
spacebanana7 ◴[] No.43718419[source]
Google isn't a monopoly in the Standard Oil sense of the term. Its ad revenue is big because it occupies so much user attention. I actually think many suggested remedies would actually make Google more profitable.

For example, prohibiting Apple-Style search deals would mean that Google gets a smaller amount of traffic, but that traffic would come with zero cost. That could end up being more profitable. A similar argument applies to Chrome or any other customer acquisition vehicle.

The real barriers to making Google competitive are fixable but require a different sort of regulation outside of antitrust.

replies(3): >>43718485 #>>43718488 #>>43720320 #
yoshicoder ◴[] No.43718485[source]
I mean it wouldn't make sense for it to be more profitable for google if there were no search deals, since otherwise they would just cancel the deal themselves. Clearly they see long term value in blocking out competition even at that high of a price
replies(3): >>43718555 #>>43718563 #>>43718575 #
blasphemers ◴[] No.43718575[source]
It depends on the what the browsers end up doing. If they just surface a select your search engine dialog during set up, most people will just select google and nothing will have changed besides the cost. If they set a non-google search engine by default, they will lose ad revenue because of people not bothering to change the default.
replies(1): >>43718694 #
1. abirch ◴[] No.43718694[source]
Depends on the default search engine. Many people went of their way to download a web browser that wasn't Internet Explorer for many years even though IE was the default.

If the default search were randomly assigned and Google investors were nefarious the investors (not Alphabet) could simply help launch 30 different subpar search engines. Then if a user landed on one of those as a default search engine: the user would switch to Google.

replies(1): >>43718924 #
2. datadrivenangel ◴[] No.43718924[source]
It would be great to separate the search index/engine from the ads and allow other search portals to pay for the index and choose how to monetize.

If google actually went about organizing the worlds information, that would be wonderful.