←back to thread

235 points colinprince | 6 comments | | HN request time: 0.424s | source | bottom
1. constantcrying ◴[] No.43717225[source]
Interesting that the fake personas are active on both reddit and 4chan, which usually are anonymous or at least pseudonymous.

The "bots are filling subreddits/image boards" has been a common conspiracy theory, usually called "dead Internet theory". Apparently it is at least partially true.

replies(4): >>43717976 #>>43718378 #>>43718837 #>>43718996 #
2. bee_rider ◴[] No.43717976[source]
I at least vaguely get the idea of having law enforcement one-on-one message people who might be planning crimes. Well, I think it should be handled with a lot of care and documentation (I mean there’s a lot of risk of entrapment with this sort of stuff, right?), but at least it is possible that it could be done in a manner than is not a net negative.

Having a bot to help radicalize people on a public, open site like Reddit seems pretty bad, though. Isn’t it more likely to produce an environment of radicalization?

replies(1): >>43718080 #
3. constantcrying ◴[] No.43718080[source]
I think that is why it was such a contentious topic. Bots inciting people on public forums is obviously very different from sting operations in small chat groups.

I can not conceive what the point would be, if not radicalizing the population.

4. Deukhoofd ◴[] No.43718378[source]
I mean, of course it is. Marketing companies have long since realized that they can have far more effective advertising by acting like humans, and that people will take a recommendation from another person more serious than a random ad. Propagandists have had the same realization.

If you consider how fast you can generate huge amount of random comments, it's basically a no-brainer that huge amounts of online comments are online generated.

The only real throttle is the social media platform itself, and how well it protects against fake accounts. I don't know how motivated Reddit really is at stopping them (engagement is engagement), and a quick check on Github shows that there are a bunch of readily available solvers for 4chans captchas.

5. oaththrowaway ◴[] No.43718837[source]
It's pretty common in fosscad (3D printed firearms subreddit), that people will get DMs from brand new accounts asking them to do illegal things. Cops/Feds are really doing the least possible to entrap people
6. ◴[] No.43718996[source]