←back to thread

842 points putzdown | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.214s | source
Show context
asdajksah2123 ◴[] No.43693223[source]
America does need to bring back manufacturing. Not because a manufacturing job that pays $25/hr is somehow better than a service job that pays $25/hr.

The US needs to bring back manufacturing for strategic reasons and in strategic areas.

And it needs to have the capability to scale up manufacturing in response to emergencies.

But also, importantly, the US doesn't need to do this by onshoring all manufacturing. Near shoring and friend shoring will have to be extremely important components of adding these capabilities, and unfortunately, teh actions the US is taking will likely hurt nearshoring and friendshoring and will end up making the US less strategically capable in manufacturing even if it's able to reshore a significant amount of manufacturing.

replies(5): >>43693268 #>>43693315 #>>43693494 #>>43693626 #>>43708779 #
elbasti ◴[] No.43693626[source]
A skilled assembly worker makes closer to $30 or $40 an hour than $25. And that doesn't account for overtime. A skilled tradesman can make $40+.

Manufacturing is skilled, well-paid labor that requires commitment, attention, and care. That is why there's a shortage of labor--not because of wages.

replies(2): >>43694159 #>>43704937 #
1. zepolen ◴[] No.43704937[source]
Manufacturing can be automated, and that's what should be done.

Chinese finds it cheaper to pay people to do it.

America will find it cheaper to build robots to do it.

Then when no one has a job America will revert back to paying people to do it.

Life will always find a way to balance everything out.