←back to thread

246 points doener | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0.001s | source
Show context
ozgune ◴[] No.43691597[source]
I had a related, but orthogonal question about multilingual LLMs.

When I ask smaller models a question in English, the model does well. When I ask the same model a question in Turkish, the answer is mediocre. When I ask the model to translate my question into English, get the answer, and translate the answer back to Turkish, the model again does well.

For example, I tried the above with Llama 3.3 70B, and asked it to plan me a 3-day trip to Istanbul. When I asked Llama to do the translations between English <> Turkish, the answer was notably better.

Anyone else observed a similar behavior?

replies(11): >>43691620 #>>43691751 #>>43691774 #>>43692427 #>>43692596 #>>43692803 #>>43692874 #>>43693906 #>>43695475 #>>43698229 #>>43698667 #
mrweasel ◴[] No.43691751[source]
Someone apparently did observe ChatGPT (I think it was ChatGPT) switch to Chinese for some parts of it's reasoning/calculations and then back to English for the final answer. That's somehow even weirder than the LLM giving different answers depending on the input.
replies(6): >>43692168 #>>43692261 #>>43692574 #>>43693043 #>>43695468 #>>43695859 #
ApolloFortyNine ◴[] No.43692168[source]
I've seen this happen as well with o3-mini, but I'm honestly not sure what triggered it. I use it all the time but have only had it switch to Chinese during reasoning maybe twice.
replies(2): >>43692757 #>>43697704 #
Telemakhos ◴[] No.43692757[source]
I've seen Grok sprinkle random Chinese characters into responses I asked for in ancient Greek and Latin.
replies(1): >>43693959 #
1. andai ◴[] No.43693959[source]
I get strange languages sprinkled through my Gemini responses, including some very obscure ones. It just randomly changes language for one or two words.
replies(1): >>43696825 #
2. genewitch ◴[] No.43696825[source]
Is it possible the "vector" is more accurate in another language? Like espirit d'esclair or schadenfreude, or any number of other things that are a single word in a language but paragraphs or more in others?
replies(1): >>43699401 #
3. sanxiyn ◴[] No.43699401[source]
Possibly. I have seen Claude switching to Russian for a word or two when it is about revolution!