←back to thread

91 points PaulHoule | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
myfonj ◴[] No.43682413[source]
> "We can expect the carbon pool stored in these forests to increase substantially,"

Interesting. I would have guessed that any kind of forests have quite limited cap how much carbon it could retain in dead wood, and that this cap will be pretty much fixed. Unless something will stop natural decay processes releasing the carbon back to the atmosphere I don't see how existing grown forest could increase its capacity, since I suppose it is already at its equilibrium.

(Unlike peatlands, where most of accumulated carbon remains underwater, so it presumably has much larger capacity.)

Simply said, without "burying or sinking wood mass" I see no easy way to prevent carbon from returning into the atmosphere. Basically if we need to take carbon from the atmosphere, we should ideally put it back from where we have been mining it for last couple of centuries.

replies(3): >>43682648 #>>43682711 #>>43683163 #
1. rypskar ◴[] No.43682648[source]
Don't forget about the root system, a large part of a tree is underground, so naturally buried
replies(1): >>43682873 #
2. myfonj ◴[] No.43682873[source]
I'd call it semi-buried, since it is not isolated from the atmosphere, so in a long term I suspect that almost all its mass gets re-circulated back again – still through microbes, fungi, insects, and perhaps living root systems of surrounding trees. (Last time I tried to get some data about how much carbon remains in the soil after aerobic wood/plants decomposition in agriculture I remember it was pretty much negligible. Forest have way higher limits for maximum soil carbon accumulation, but this limit is reportedly reached after about three centuries of uninterrupted growth.)
replies(1): >>43684293 #
3. throwup238 ◴[] No.43684293[source]
Depends on the ecosystem. Anything embedded into bogs or peatland like roots will generally not decay at all, instead building up a very thick layer of captured carbon as peat.

Plants get most of their carbon from CO2 anyway, so in most cases carbon accumulates in the loam (outside of intensive agriculture at least). They produce far more than decomposers have a use for and that's how CO2 accumulates in soil. It only needs to be replenished by the rest of the carbon cycle because of erosion.