←back to thread

118 points blondie9x | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.2s | source
Show context
api ◴[] No.43673389[source]
Seattle, meaning the city, right?

When people get married and think about settling down and maybe having kids, they usually leave high cost of living cities. They want stability, something they can own or rent long term, and usually more space, especially if kids are coming.

Sometimes they move to the suburbs, sometimes across the country.

The only people who stay tend to be rich people who can actually afford to get some space and stability in the city. Even then many of those decide to leave anyway for other reasons, again especially if they want kids.

High cost city centers are basically an extension of college dorms at this point. They are where people go to start their careers or level up, not stay.

This is like saying “study shows that most people in a shopping mall are looking to buy something” then extrapolating some larger conclusion from that.

replies(2): >>43673552 #>>43673857 #
trollbridge ◴[] No.43673857[source]
Of course, this pattern of human settlement is silly. Cities used to be hospitable to families, often with multiple generations living in them. Instead of needing a daycare and lots of miles in a car, grandparents and relatives were nearby to help with young children.

On the other hand, forcing people outside of the city to afford a family means more GDP from building roads, selling tyres, replacing cars, petrol sales, oil refining…

replies(2): >>43674283 #>>43675628 #
1. watwut ◴[] No.43675628[source]
I read an article just today about how parents today expect a lot more childcare from their grandmoms then they used to be. Where grand parents in the past were expected to yell at kids here and there when those misbehaved or be their friends, they were not expected to be full caregiver the way they are now. They used to have their own things to do - whether work or fun. Grandparents as a complete replacement of a daycare where she (it is gendered) has to do all of it was not a thing. And the expectations on childcare were much smaller then today.

Grandparent to take care of a kid an afternoon a week or so was a thing. Grandparent watching a kid every day whole day, not really.