←back to thread

43 points rustoo | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
slashdev ◴[] No.43665509[source]
Cracking down on legal immigrants, skilled immigrants makes no sense. That’s what built America. Cracking down on illegal immigration makes plenty of sense. I hope the administration can see the difference.
replies(3): >>43665543 #>>43665547 #>>43665732 #
FirmwareBurner ◴[] No.43665547[source]
>Cracking down on legal immigrants, skilled immigrants makes no sense

It makes sense when thy engage in political activism or become dissidents. Just because they're skilled doesn't mean they can't be legally causing troubles at the same time.

No country tolerates foreigners moving in and acting against the country that took them in. Well, maybe Germany does.

When you emigrate somewhere on a visa, you're a guest in the country who's tolerated as long as you follow the rules and contribute to society, the moment you start causing trouble with protests or become a nuisance, you're out. Simple.

replies(4): >>43665560 #>>43665586 #>>43665602 #>>43665986 #
Krssst ◴[] No.43665586[source]
They're not acting against the country but against the government. The country may very well benefit largely from the government being impeded.
replies(1): >>43665592 #
FirmwareBurner ◴[] No.43665592[source]
The government gave them the visa. When you apply for the visa you interact with the government and they give you the visa. If you check the terms and conditions of your visa, they're tied to you following the laws and not causing any issues otherwise it gets revoked.

The moment you try to swing a punch against the government that gave you that visa, then that contract is void, and you're out.

I don't see how this is an issue. Are you OK with foreigners coming into your country and starting to go against your democratically elected government(in principle, not just the orange man specifically)? I don't know anyone who wants that. Let citizens deal with their elected government, you can too once you become a citizen, if you want.

replies(4): >>43665680 #>>43665730 #>>43665733 #>>43673052 #
1. Krssst ◴[] No.43665733[source]
You can express disagreement loudly with the power in place while still following the laws and not causing "issues" in the way most people think about issues.

Whether visa holders have such right depends on the countries however; I don't believe France has such restrictions (https://www.service-public.fr/particuliers/vosdroits/F2190 does not mention "political activities" as a valid motive for refusing entry). I think some other countries do restrict political activities for non-citizens.