I'd love to see a reproducible example of these tools producing something that is exceptional. Or a clear reproducible example of using them the right way.
I've used them some (sorry I didn't make detailed notes about my usage, probably used them wrong) but pretty much there are always subtle bugs that if I didn't know better I would have overlooked.
I don't doubt people find them useful, personally I'd rather spend my time learning about things that interest me instead of spending money learning how to prompt a machine to do something I can do myself that I also enjoy doing.
I think a lot of the disagreements on hn about this tech is that both sides are mostly on the extremes of either "it doesn't work and at and is pointless" or "it's amazing and makes me 100x more productive" and not much discussion about the mid-ground of it works for some stuff and knowing what stuff it works well on makes it useful but it won't solve all your problems.