←back to thread

121 points tylerg | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.194s | source
Show context
zahlman ◴[] No.43659511[source]
Okay, but like.

If you do have that skill to communicate clearly and describe the requirements of a novel problem, why is the AI still useful? Actually writing the code should be relatively trivial from there. If it isn't, that points to a problem with your tools/architecture/etc. Programmers IMX are, on average, far too tolerant of boilerplate.

replies(5): >>43659634 #>>43659667 #>>43659773 #>>43660939 #>>43661579 #
geor9e ◴[] No.43659773[source]
>Actually writing the code should be relatively trivial

For you, maybe. This statement assumes years of grueling training to become bilingual in a foreign programming language. And I can't type at 1000 tokens/s personally - sometimes I just want to press the voice dictate key and blab for five seconds and move on to something actually interesting.

replies(1): >>43659865 #
zahlman ◴[] No.43659865[source]
>This statement assumes years of grueling training to become bilingual in a foreign programming language

...So, less experienced programmers are supposed to be happy that they can save time with the same technology that will convince their employers that a human isn't necessary for the position?

(And, frankly, I've overall quite enjoyed the many years I've put into the craft.)

replies(1): >>43660712 #
geor9e ◴[] No.43660712[source]
You're seeing this entirely from the perspective of people who do programming as their job. I'm seeing it from the perspective of the other 99% of society. It feels really good that they're no longer gatekept by the rigid and cryptic interfaces that prevented them from really communicating with their computer, just because it couldn't speak their native tongue.
replies(3): >>43661007 #>>43661426 #>>43662725 #
1. Arn_Thor ◴[] No.43662725[source]
Yep! I’m digitally literate but can’t do anything more advanced than “hello world”. Never had the time or really interest in learning programming.

In the last year I’ve built scripts and even full fledged apps with GUIs to solve a number of problems and automate a bunch of routine tasks at work and in my hobbies. It feels like I woke up with a superpower.

And I’ve learned a ton too, about how the plumbing works, but I still can’t write code on my own. That makes me useful but dependent on the AI.